V3Cars
V3Cars
iconUpcoming Cars
iconPopular Cars
iconLatest Cars
iconElectric Cars
News

Stay updated with the latest automotive news.

Reviews

Discover expert car reviews and comparisons.

Videos

Watch in-depth video reviews, comparison, variants explained and more.

Calculators

Estimate costs and savings with our handy automotive calculators.

Buy, Sell & Renew

Simplify your car ownership journey with our buying, selling, and renewal tools.

Others

Explore additional resources and comparisons for car enthusiasts.

HomeNews5 Reasons Why Electric Is Not The Future Hydrogen Is

Published : 30 July 2021

Read Time : 5 min

Author: Mahesh Yadav

A recent report in New York Times with deep journalistic insights claims that Toyota are lobbying against mandating electric cars. More and more governments around the world are outlining deadlines for the end of petrol and diesel engines. Meanwhile, Toyota remain committed to hybrids before transitioning to hydrogen fuel cell vehicles.

 

AD
Electric Cars future in India

Do you think electric cars are the future. I believe they could serve as a stop-gap solution before we move to a fuel source with energy density comparable to that of petrol and diesel. Here are my 5 reasons why hydrogen can take off as the main source of energy for transportation.

1. Weight Penalty

When you top up your fuel tank, you end up lugging that extra weight wherever you go. As you drive, the car gets lighter and it’s lightest just before gassing out.

In an electric vehicle, you’re carrying around the weight of the batteries all the time. Even when you have almost zero charge left, it’s still as heavy as it was when you unplugged it from the wall. Hence, if you choose a car with a bigger battery for a longer range, you’re paying a penalty in efficiency as you’re lugging around that extra weight 95% of the time just as insurance to save you in 5% of the situations.

But, it doesn’t matter. For a passenger car, we have probably already found a sweet balance. Around 300 - 500km is a range that’ll satisfy most car buyers. For the shipping industry, however, this loss in efficiency comes at a cost. A truck pays a shipping company’s bills, the driver’s salary, and its own maintenance and fuel costs by moving a lot of stuff from point A to B. If that truck also has to haul a 2000kg battery pack, then that’s 2000kg less cargo that it can carry and safely handle on the roads. That’s a loss-making deal.

Similarly, for aviation, large ships, and buses, it makes sense to go with something more energy-dense like hydrogen as it can carry significantly more energy per kilogram of weight.

Similarly, for a motorcycle, weight reduction is critical. A 5kg lighter motorcycle feels like it’s 20kg lighter when riding as it handles, brakes, and accelerates better. A lighter motorcycle also suffers less wear and tear and is more efficient. Here, again, it’s a lot more difficult to find that balance in range, performance, handling, upfront cost and efficiency with an electric drivetrain.

2. Charging Times

While DC fast chargers are cropping up left and right, a full top-up in an electric car is still far slower than pumping fuel into the tank. However, topping up a hydrogen tank can be just as quick as filling fuel at a petrol station.

That’s not even the darkest side of a fast charger though. A DC charger tries to push as much current into the battery as it can. This heats up the battery pack and puts it through several cycles of rapid temperature fluctuations. This cycle reduces the life of the battery pack in the long run and may force you to prematurely replace the battery.

3. No Revenue

Now let’s crunch some numbers and see how the money flows here in India.

You buy a car, which is taxed like a sin good. On a big SUV, this can be almost as much as 50%. When you buy an electric car, you pay 12% GST and little to no tax in many states.

You visit fuel stations and buy petrol or diesel, both of which carry about 250% tax depending on the crude oil prices and USD exchange rate. You will mostly charge your electric car at home. As an electric car owner, not only are you not paying your share of taxes, which you’d have paid with fuel, you’re also using subsidised electricity.

If you end up installing a solar roof at home, then you won’t even pay that subsidised rate. Finding out that the common man can power his home and run his car for free will certainly get the attention of lawmakers regardless of their political affiliations.

If you are running the government, ask yourself if you’d like to encourage people to stop paying taxes on new car purchases and fuel. Perhaps the government is under international and social pressure to go green and combat climate change. But these subsidies are only temporary at best. Sooner or later, the government will find a way to come after you and make you pay all that you “owed”.

From the manufacturers’ point of view, selling a car is barely half the story. After factoring in the R&D, shipping, advertising, salaries, loans to maintain an inventory, the lease on the dealership property and many other things, there’s very little profit to be made in terms of return on investment. When you compare that with a service centre, the difference is night and day. For a service centre, the dealer doesn’t have to pay for a flashy location, lower inventory costs and it offers consistent income with way better ROI than running a sales outlet.

With an electric car, there are fewer moving parts. So, it barely needs any routine maintenance. This will make it extremely difficult for the dealers to survive. Like a petrol or diesel car, the fuel-cell car is complex enough that people will religiously follow the service schedule. For the dealer and carmaker, the fuel cell in the car is a money-printing machine like the petrol/diesel engine.

Hence, it’s in the carmakers’ best interest to push the lawmakers towards investing in hydrogen.

4. Rare Earth Mining

You probably already know that the battery pack is the single most expensive component in an electric car. Making batteries requires mining rare earth minerals. Due to the sudden rise in demand for electric cars, there’s an equally big spike in demand for research and exploration of rare earth minerals.

Africa, reportedly, has the biggest source of rare earths right now and countries in that continent aren’t all that rich. Huge demand is likely to indirectly lead to malpractices in the mining process and the use of forced and even child labour. If news reports in the future corroborate my speculations, it could help subside demand for EVs as buyers look for ways to keep a clear conscience.

5. Toxic Waste

You could use an old car battery pack as a backup power source for your home. But eventually, it will get to a point where it’s no longer feasible to spend so much time and energy into a battery pack that can’t hold much of it. We’ll eventually have to dispose of it. That’s when we might scramble to figure out a way to save the earth from the thing that was supposed to save the earth.

AD

Did you find this information helpful?

Mahesh Yadav
Mahesh Yadav

Content Head

Mahesh is a fan of compact, quirky and underrated vehicles that punch above their weight. Multix, Nano and Navi are his favourites.

Comments

0 comments

U
Loading comments...

Car News Update

View All Latest News
PUC Certificate Rules Updated – Validity Periods Explained

PUC Certificate Validity Periods Revised Based On Vehicle Age And Emission Norms

The government has amended Rule 115(7) of the Central Motor Vehicles Rules to revise the validity periods of Pollution Under Control (PUC) certificates. The new framework, notified by the Ministry of Road Transport and Highways (MoRTH), links certificate validity to a vehicle’s emission standard, age and transport category, with longer validity periods for newer BS6 vehicles.

Nikil Jonathan
Hyundai Neira EV Revealed – Kia Carens Clavis EV Twin

Hyundai Neira EV Revealed As Kia Carens Clavis EV Twin – India Launch Yet To Be Confirmed

Hyundai have unveiled the production-spec Neira EV, a 7-seater electric MPV for the Indonesian market. The new model is a badge-engineered sibling of the Kia Carens Clavis EV sold in India, sharing its overall design, lighting elements and features. Hyundai will showcase the Neira at the 2026 Gaikindo Auto Week (GJAW), scheduled to take place in Indonesia from November 20 to 29.

Nikil Jonathan
Hyundai Verna Scores 5-Star Bharat NCAP Safety Rating

2026 Hyundai Verna Scores 5-Star Bharat NCAP Safety Rating

The 2026 Hyundai Verna has secured a 5-star Bharat NCAP safety rating for both adult and child occupant protection. The sedan scored 28.22 points out of 32 in adult occupant protection (AOP) and 44 points out of 49 in child occupant protection (COP).

Nikil Jonathan
Hyundai Creta EV Price Hike November 2026

November 2026: Hyundai Creta EV Price Change - Increased By Up To Rs. 40,000

Hyundai have revised the prices of the Creta EV for November 2026. The Smart (O) and Excellence variants with the 51.4kWh battery pack have received a price hike of Rs. 40,000 each, while the prices of the remaining variants are unchanged.

Navneet Kumar
Tata Sierra EV Gets 5-Star Bharat NCAP Safety Rating

Tata Sierra EV Scores 5-Star Bharat NCAP Safety Rating

The Tata Sierra EV has secured a 5-star safety rating in Bharat NCAP crash tests, scoring 30.62 points out of 32 for adult occupant protection and 45 points out of 49 for child occupant protection. The crash tests were conducted using the top-spec Empowered A 75kWh QWD variant. However, the safety rating applies to all variants of the electric SUV.

Nikil Jonathan
VinFast VF5 - What To Expect From Upcoming Tata Nexon EV Rival

VinFast VF 5 – What To Expect From Upcoming Tata Nexon EV Rival?

VinFast have confirmed plans to launch the VF 5 electric SUV in India. The upcoming model will become the Vietnamese carmaker’s most affordable offering in the country and is expected to compete against the Tata Nexon EV and other B2-segment electric SUVs. The India-bound model is expected to be the recently revealed VF 5 facelift, which gets revised exterior styling, a more practical cabin and larger battery options.

Nikil Jonathan
Mini Cooper SE, Paul Smith Edition Bookings Open

Mini Cooper SE And Paul Smith Edition Bookings Open

Mini India have opened pre-launch bookings for the all-electric Mini Cooper SE and the new Mini Paul Smith Edition. Prices, variant-wise details and launch timelines are yet to be announced.

Nikil Jonathan
Mahindra XEV 9S Gets 5-Star Bharat NCAP Safety Rating

Mahindra XEV 9S Scores 5-Star Bharat NCAP Safety Rating

The Mahindra XEV 9S has secured a 5-star safety rating in the Bharat New Car Assessment Programme (Bharat NCAP) crash tests. The 3-row electric SUV scored 31.15 out of 32 points for Adult Occupant Protection (AOP) and 45 out of 49 points for Child Occupant Protection (COP), earning the highest 5-star rating in both categories.

Nikil Jonathan
Audi A5 – What To Expect: Launch, Engine, Features And Design

2027 Audi A5 – What To Expect: Design, Features, Powertrain And Launch Timeline

The new-generation Audi A5 was spotted testing in India ahead of its expected launch in February 2027. The A5 will replace the A4 in Audi India’s lineup and compete against the BMW 3 Series and Mercedes-Benz C-Class. It will be locally assembled as part of Audi’s 3-model launch programme for India.

Nikil Jonathan
JSW Motors Website Live – Combat SUV Launch On December 4

JSW Motors Website Goes Live Ahead Of Combat SUV Debut

JSW Motors have launched their official website ahead of the brand’s debut in India on December 3, 2026. The website allows prospective buyers to register their interest in the company’s first SUV, the Combat, which is expected to be unveiled on December 4. However, the company is not accepting bookings yet.

Nikil Jonathan
2027 Tata Nexon Spied With Curvv Alloy Wheels, New Front Design

2027 Tata Nexon Spied With Curvv Alloy Wheels, New Front Design

The next-generation Tata Nexon was spotted testing again, revealing more details about its exterior design and features. Codenamed ‘Garud’, the new Nexon is expected to debut in 2027 with a redesigned exterior and interior. The latest spy shots reveal Curvv-like alloy wheels, rear disc brakes, a front radar module and a new rear windscreen design. Interior spy shots have also hinted at 2 freestanding displays.

Nikil Jonathan
Upcoming Cars In November 2026 – Mercedes, Denza, Mini & BMW

Upcoming Cars In November 2026 - Mercedes-Benz GLC Electric, Denza, Mini & BMW

The Indian car market is set to see several new launches in November 2026, with luxury electric cars and performance models making up much of the upcoming lineup.

Nikil Jonathan

Expert Car Reviews

View All Car Reviews
2026 Maruti Baleno Facelift Review In Pictures

2026 Maruti Baleno Facelift Photo Gallery - Design, Features And Drive Review

The 2026 Maruti Baleno facelift gets a new 1.2L 3-cylinder petrol engine, level 2 ADAS and ventilated front seats. We drove it to see whether the new engine and added features make up for the loss of the old 4-cylinder’s refinement.

Aryan Tyagi
2026 Tata Curvv Series X Photo Gallery - Exterior And Interior

2026 Tata Curvv Series X Photo Gallery - Exterior, Interior And Features

Tata have launched the 2026 Curvv Series X with a simpler variant lineup and several features moved further down the range. We got a closer look at the new Curvv Series X, including the Pure X Plus and Creative X Plus variants. In this detailed photo gallery, we take you through their exterior differences, interior, features, rear-seat space and the construction of Tata’s R-Comfort seats.

Siddharth
2026 Maruti Brezza Facelift

2026 Maruti Brezza Facelift Worth Buying?

The 2026 Maruti Brezza adds a 1.0L turbo petrol engine, more features and a 5-star Bharat NCAP rating. Its underbody CNG cylinder also frees up the full 328L boot. However, not every powertrain and variant offers equally strong value. We explain which Brezza to buy and when a rival makes more sense.

Siddharth
2026 Maruti Brezza 1.0L Turbo First Drive Review

2026 Maruti Arena Brezza 1.0L Turbo Manual First Drive Review

We drove the 2026 Maruti Arena Brezza with its new 1.0L turbo petrol engine and 6-speed manual transmission. We covered roughly 50km over about 2 hours at speeds representative of typical city driving. Here are my impressions of its performance, refinement, mileage, highway manners, ride and everyday usability.

Jagdev Kalsi
2026 Brezza CNG 328L Boot Space Explained

2026 Maruti Brezza CNG 328L Boot Space Explained

The 2026 Maruti Brezza CNG now has its cylinder mounted below the body, allowing it to retain the petrol version’s full 328L boot space. We examine the practical improvement, dimensions, ground clearance and boot-related features offered with each CNG variant.

Siddharth
2026 Brezza Turbo Vs 1.5L Petrol - Which One To Buy?

2026 Maruti Brezza 1.0L Turbo Vs 1.5L Petrol - Which One To Buy?

The 2026 Maruti Brezza offers a new 1.0L turbo petrol engine alongside the familiar 1.5L normal petrol. Both engines come with a new 6-speed manual transmission. The smaller turbo costs less and offers more power, torque and features, while the 1.5L petrol claims better mileage. We compare the 2 to determine which Brezza petrol-manual makes more sense.

Siddharth
Fronx Petrol Vs CNG

Maruti Arena Fronx Petrol Vs CNG Mileage And Running Cost

If you’re wondering whether to buy the Maruti Suzuki Fronx petrol or CNG, this article will help you make a data-backed decision. We compare the latest ex-showroom prices, official mileage figures and current fuel prices in Delhi to calculate the running cost difference between the Fronx petrol and CNG variants. We also calculate how many kilometres you need to drive the Fronx CNG to recover its higher upfront cost over the petrol variant.

Prathu Sharma
2026 Honda ZR-V Hybrid Photo Gallery Exterior Interior Features

2026 Honda ZR-V Hybrid Photo Gallery

The 2026 Honda ZR-V Hybrid is set to launch in India as Honda’s new flagship SUV on May 22, 2026. Positioned above the Elevate, the ZR-V will rival premium SUVs like the Volkswagen Tiguan R-Line and Skoda Kodiaq with its strong hybrid powertrain, premium interior and advanced features. In this detailed photo gallery, we take a closer look at the ZRV Hybrid’s design, cabin, practicality, safety features and hybrid technology.

Siddharth
2026 Tata Punch EV Variant-Wise Battery Options

2026 Tata Punch EV Variant-Wise Powertrain Options – Battery, Range & Specifications

The 2026 Tata Punch EV is available with multiple battery pack and motor configurations, giving buyers the flexibility to choose between affordability and longer driving range. Depending on the variant, the new Punch EV offers different power outputs, battery capacities and claimed range. In this article, we break down the 2026 Punch EV’s variant-wise powertrain options and check out which variants get the 30kWh and 40kWh battery packs, along with their performance specifications, so you can pick the variant that best suits your needs.

Nikil Jonathan
Maruti Fronx 1.0L Turbo Petrol-Auto Actual City, Highway Mileage Test

Maruti Fronx 1.0L Turbo Petrol-Auto Mileage Test: Real World City, Highway Fuel Efficiency

In this article, we’ll present the data based on V3Cars mileage test and inform you about what real-world fuel efficiency you can expect from the Maruti Fronx 1.0L turbo petrol-automatic in city and highway driving conditions. We’ll also find out how much the mileage numbers deviate from the manufacturer-claimed fuel efficiency figures. The information presented in this article will also help you learn about the mileage differences you can expect when driving in the city vs driving on the highway.

Arpit Gupta
2025 Kia Syros Features Over Kia Sonet

10 Features New Kia Syros Gets Over Kia Sonet

Kia unveiled their all-new B2-segment SUV, the 2025 Syros, on December 19, 2024. While Kia India are yet to reveal the variant-wise prices of the 2025 Syros, it is expected to slot in between the Sonet B2-SUV and Seltos C-SUV.

Nikil Jonathan
Hyundai Exter 1.2L Petrol-Auto Actual City, Highway Mileage Test

Hyundai Exter 1.2L Petrol-Auto Mileage Test: Real World City, Highway Fuel Efficiency

In this article, we’ll present the data based on V3Cars mileage test and inform you about what real-world fuel efficiency you can expect from the Hyundai Exter 1.2L petrol-automatic in city and highway driving conditions. We’ll also find out how much the mileage numbers deviate from the manufacturer-claimed fuel efficiency figures. The information presented in this article will also help you learn about the mileage differences you can expect when driving in the city vs driving on the highway.

Arpit Gupta
google news
AD
AD